Format guide
HEIC vs PNG: What's the Difference in Size and Support?
The Short Answer
- PNG is lossless, so the same photo usually ends up several times larger than the HEIC it was opened from — and just as sharp as when it was written.
- HEIC is small because HEVC throws away detail the eye is unlikely to notice; the pixels are close, but they are not identical.
- PNG opens everywhere, while an iPhone HEIC often will not open on Windows or pass a web upload form at all.
| Format | How it compresses | Typical file size | Transparency | EXIF data | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HEIC | Lossy (HEVC) | Small — around half a JPG | Supported; photos rarely use it | Kept | Phone storage, Apple-only sharing |
| PNG | Lossless | Often several times the HEIC | Yes — full alpha channel | Kept; some platforms strip it | Editing, graphics, logos, cut-outs |
Why a PNG Is Several Times Larger
The HEIC vs PNG size gap comes down to what each compressor is allowed to throw away. PNG is lossless: every pixel that goes in comes out identical, which is why it is trusted for editing, screenshots, and archiving. Its compressor only removes statistical repetition, so the fine, irregular detail in a photograph — noise, gradients, texture — all stays in the file. HEIC compresses with HEVC and deliberately discards detail the eye is unlikely to miss, spending its bits on what remains. Nothing was thrown away in the PNG, so nothing can be saved.
What PNG Carries That a Photo Rarely Has
PNG stores a full alpha channel, so any pixel can be partly or fully transparent, and every browser and editor honours it. HEIC can store alpha as well; transparency is not what separates the two formats. Practice does. An iPhone photo is opaque to begin with — the camera records a scene, not a cut-out — so the HEIC vs PNG question about transparency only matters once an image has been cut out: a logo, a product shot, a graphic with soft edges. There PNG is the more predictable carrier, because its alpha support is older and more widely implemented.
Where Each File Opens
A PNG opens in every browser, in Windows with no add-ons, in old editions of Photoshop, and in design tools that have never heard of HEVC. A HEIC does not. Windows needs the HEIF and HEVC extensions before it will draw a thumbnail, and most web upload forms accept a short list — usually JPG, PNG, and GIF — then reject the rest. That is why the HEIC vs PNG decision is often made by the receiving form rather than by the photographer: a file that cannot be uploaded is worth nothing.
Does a PNG Keep EXIF Data?
Both formats can carry it. An iPhone HEIC records camera model, lens, exposure, timestamp, and often GPS coordinates; PNG can hold the same fields in its metadata chunks. What happens next is less certain: many social platforms and upload services strip metadata on arrival to protect privacy, so a file that still had its EXIF on disk can land without a date or a location. On that point the HEIC vs PNG comparison is a draw — and the stripping happens at the destination, not inside the file.
HEIC vs WebP: The Option in Between
For anything headed to a web page, the heic vs webp question often replaces the heic vs png one. WebP can be lossy or lossless, comes out far smaller than PNG for a photograph, and supports transparency, so it can stand in for both formats here. Its weakness is the mirror image of HEIC's: browsers read it, but older desktop software may not. The heic vs webp size difference is real and narrow; the gap in support is what usually decides between them.
When to Export a PNG and When to Keep the HEIC
The HEIC vs PNG choice is really a choice between keeping the original and making a copy that opens anywhere. Export a PNG when the file will be edited again, when it is a graphic or a cut-out, or when it must open on a machine with no HEVC decoder. Keep the HEIC when the photo goes back to a phone or a Mac, or when storage matters more than universality.
For a plain photo that only has to open somewhere, a JPG is the smaller safe copy: HEIC to JPG handles that in the browser, and HEIC to PNG keeps the alpha channel when there is one to keep. If you are weighing those two, HEIC vs JPG covers the quality side. The HEIC converter on the home page works the same way: the file stays on your device and no account is needed.
FAQ
Why is a PNG so much bigger than the HEIC it came from?
Because nothing was thrown away. The HEIC was written with lossy HEVC compression, and opening it does not restore the detail that was already discarded. The PNG then stores every pixel exactly, so the same picture takes far more space.
Is the transparent background still there after the file becomes a PNG?
Yes, if there was one. PNG stores an alpha channel, so a cut-out with a transparent background keeps it. An iPhone photo starts with an opaque background, so its PNG looks identical — there is no transparency to carry over.
When should I use PNG instead of JPG?
Use PNG for graphics, screenshots, logos, anything with transparency, or an image that will be edited again and again without degrading. Use JPG for ordinary photographs that only need a small file. PNG is the better master copy; JPG is the better delivery copy.
Will a PNG open on the device that refused the HEIC?
Almost always. PNG is read by every browser, by Windows with no extra software, and by old editions of Photoshop. That is the main practical reason to switch: the picture no longer depends on whether the other machine can decode HEVC.